Moderators can edit, move, lock and delete threads and posts, and can suspend or ban accounts. Administrators can do all of that and can also change roles and grant badges.
When we act on your post, we will normally tell you what rule it was and what we did. We do not always do this in public, because naming someone in a thread tends to start the pile-on we are trying to end.
The usual ladder is:
- A quiet word, usually a private note.
- A formal warning, recorded against your account.
- A temporary suspension, typically between one day and thirty days.
- A permanent ban.
We skip straight to the end of that ladder for hate speech, harassment campaigns, doxxing, threats, sexual content involving minors, and ban evasion. There is no first warning for those.
Being stained sits beside that ladder rather than on it. An account is stained three ways: its reputation falls to the bottom tier, it is caught being a second account for the same person, or an administrator decides it. While an account is stained:
- Everything it writes waits for a staff member before anyone else can see it.
- It can only post on Feedback and Bugs and Stained Appeals, and in threads it started itself.
- Its profile shows nothing but its name and the mark, and it cannot open anyone else's profile either. The social half of the site closes in both directions.
- Where the cause was a second account, the other account's name is shown on the stained profile for anyone to read.
- The addresses it was used from are recorded. As said above, that alone never restricts anyone else.
Catfish. Getting caught running a second account is the one thing here that gets posted in public. An automated account called Catfish opens a thread on the Catfish board titled with the original account's name, listing every duplicate found and when each was made. The thread is locked the moment it is made, so it is a record and not somewhere to pile on, and the harassment rules above apply to talking about it anywhere else.
The original account is not restricted by this and does not lose anything. It keeps its posts, its badges and its reputation. What it loses is the ability to pretend it did not happen.
If staff decide the detection was wrong, the mark is cleared and the Catfish thread comes down with it, because an accusation that has been withdrawn should not outlive the withdrawal. Say so in Stained Appeals.
Marks. There is a set of badges nobody wants: Stained, Catfish, Liar, Misinformer, Leaker, Pile-On, Vote Farmer, Doxxer, Bigot, Art Thief, Spoiler, Brigader, Serial Reporter, Stalker, Pirate and Impostor. They are not rewards. They are put on an account by an administrator for the thing they are named after, and they behave differently from every other badge:
- A mark is worn on every post you make and on your profile, ahead of anything you chose to wear, and you cannot take it off in your settings.
- A mark does not expire and is not lifted with a stain. Only an administrator can remove one, and they do so when they decide it was wrong, not because time has passed.
- Stained is the mark of a stain and the one exception to the above: it comes off when an administrator lifts the stain, and not before. Catfish is put on by the software at the same moment an account is stained for being a second account, and lifting that stain does not remove it. If the detection is found to be wrong, it comes off with the Catfish thread.
- Every mark is recorded with who put it on and when, and you can appeal it under Appeals below.
A mark is meant to be permanent and public. That is a heavy thing to do to someone, so it is done by a person, for a specific rule broken, and you are told which.
Nothing is deleted. Your posts stay where they are, and you keep reading the whole site.
Getting unstained
This is meant to be a door, not a wall. There is one way out and it is the same for everyone:
- Post in Stained Appeals. Say what happened and, if the stain was earned, say so. Staff are not looking for grovelling. They are looking for whether you understand what went wrong.
- Your post waits for approval like everything else, so give it a day.
- An administrator reads it and answers in the thread.
If they lift it, and the stain came from votes, your reputation is reset to zero at the same time. You do not have to climb back from the bottom, because with two boards open and every post queued that would be impossible by design, and a punishment you cannot finish serving is just a ban with extra steps. You start again at neutral.
If they do not lift it, they will say why, and you can ask again after thirty days. If the stain was a mistake by the software, say so plainly and it will be lifted with no conditions at all.
Only an administrator can lift a stain. Every stain and every lift is recorded with who did it and when.